Who is Online

We have 257 guests and no members online

War with Armenia

 

Leaving Baku we would need to head north into Georgia because the border with Armenia is a war zone.  So it's not possible to cross it, at least not in a tour coach, with any safety. The present enmity dates back to 1917 but the roots are much earlier, perhaps going back to the 12th century and the arrival of Islam; or to the fourth century and the arrival of Christianity; or perhaps even to the 5th century BCE and the arrival of Zoroastrianism?

Coming forward to modern times, from the turn of the 19th century Tsar Nicholas II (the bloody) had made a series of catastrophic military mistakes that got worse at the start of the First World War.  So Russia was in turmoil, culminating in the first revolution at the beginning of 1917.  As a result the Russian Army of the Caucuses was withdrawn and the (Turkish) Ottoman Empire saw an opportunity to invade.  Muslim Azerbaijanis for their part saw their chance for independence.  But it did not go smoothly.  A bloody civil war broke out between ethnic (Christian) Armenians, who remembered the Armenian Genocide in Turkey, and (Muslim) Azerbaijanis, supporting the Turks.

Then in October there was a second, Bolshevik, Revolution in Russia and the Russian Civil War began. In Transcaucasia, particularly in Georgia, the Bolsheviks had been opposed by the Mensheviks (see later) and now inroads were being made by the anti-revolutionary forces known as White Russians (remember Dr Zhivago), who enjoyed initial military success here with western support. 

 

See album See album

David Lean (movie) and Boris Pasternak (book) - a very popular story in the West during the Cold War
source: public domain

So neither side were in a position to stop the sectarian violence in Azerbaijan. In 1918 a new, but short lived, Azerbaijani Democratic Republic was declared by the separatists but failed to stop the fighting.  Social stability was not restored until 1920 when the Russian Civil War ended in a Bolshevik victory.  The Russians then prevailed and an Azerbaijani Soviet was established under Lenin.  People who had taken part in that violence were still unsatisfied and old memories, passed on to new generations, die hard.  So traditional enmities and disputes over territory flared up again when the Soviet Union collapsed and the Russians withdrew, yet again.  Our local guide made his still bitter partisan feelings on these matters quite clear.

 

No comments

Travel

Berlin

 

 

 

I'm a bit daunted writing about Berlin.  

Somehow I'm happy to put down a couple of paragraphs about many other cities and towns I've visited but there are some that seem too complicated for a quick 'off the cuff' summary.  Sydney of course, my present home town, and past home towns like New York and London.  I know just too much about them for a glib first impression.

Although I've never lived there I've visited Berlin on several occasions for periods of up to a couple of weeks.  I also have family there and have been introduced to their circle of friends.

So I decided that I can't really sum Berlin up, any more that I can sum up London or New York, so instead I should pick some aspects of uniqueness to highlight. 

Read more: Berlin

Fiction, Recollections & News

Napoleon - the movie

 

As holiday entertainment goes, one could do worse than spend two-and-a-half hours (157 minutes) with Napoleon.

Wikipedia tells us: "Napoleon is a 2023 epic historical drama film directed and produced by Ridley Scott and written by David Scarpa. Based on the story of Napoleon Bonaparte, primarily depicting the French leader's rise to power as well as his relationship with his [first} wife, Joséphine, the film stars Joaquin Phoenix as Napoleon and Vanessa Kirby as Joséphine."

The many battle scenes are spectacular and have been praised for their accuracy.

Read more: Napoleon - the movie

Opinions and Philosophy

Energy woes in South Australia

 

 

 

 

South Australia has run aground on the long foreseen wind energy reef - is this a lee shore?

Those of you who have followed my energy commentaries published here over the past six years will know that this situation was the entirely predictable outcome of South Australia pressing on with an unrealistic renewable energy target dependent on wind generated electricity, subsidised by market distorting Large-scale Generation Certificates (LGCs) (previously called RECs in some places on this website - the name was changed after their publication).  

Read more: Energy woes in South Australia

Terms of Use

Terms of Use                                                                    Copyright