Who is Online

We have 25 guests and no members online

Bagan

This place is famous for its 2200 temples and pagodas, the remains of some ten thousand at its peak.  Maybe we should have come here first.  By this point in our trip this was all getting a bit much. 

Some say Bagan is the equivalent of Angkor Watt but I couldn’t see it, except that it is much larger in overall scale.  Individually the structures are not impressive. 

 

Bagan
Bagan - much the same in every direction

 

There is an old city wall and the remains of a moat but it is nowhere near as impressive as huge and the still functioning moat at Angkor Wat.

Bagan was built over hundreds of years on individual commissions.

We climbed to the top of a smaller semi-ruined pagoda near the hotel that provided a panoramic view well into the distance.  My father-in-law and his mate could have knocked a small one up in a month or two.  At some time not too long ago this one had been extensively repaired with modern materials and it is alleged that many have been growing in this manner since Bagan became a tourist attraction.  30,000 coming up.

 

climbing up bricks and mortar
view1 view2

Two others climbing up, original construction detail, panorama from the top, very similar one nearby

 

Angkor was built by a true tyrant.  It required the combined efforts of tens of thousands of craftsmen and unknown numbers of slave labourers for his lifetime.  And it remains unfinished. Even the stones lining the moat are works of art.  

This is the work of dilatants. Sure, like Angkor it’s a vast monument to man’s hubris, or perhaps a vain attempt to avoid hubris.  It’s the detritus of hundreds of years of futile construction attempting to secure a life after this.  It’s  akin to the Moai on Easter island and just as pointless. 

I gave it a chance.  But where is the craftsmanship?  I looked in vain for huge stones polished to a mirror or cut so fine a hair could not fit between or for stones covered in carvings of detailed subtlety.  What I got was a standardised brick and mortar structure, four big Buddha’s facing the points of the compass and numerous little ones in the connecting corridors. 

 

Numerous golden Buddhas - some very big

 

The largest structure in town is the modern Cultural Museum built in a couple of years, albeit with modern methods.  Even the largest of the historical structures would take a hundred brick layers next to no time.  Most of the detail being in the brick design, repetitive clay moulding. 

Architectural they are repetitious and boring with no particular merit except that one of the more recent ones features properly arched buttresses, unknown at Angkor.  This gave it the air of a western church.  It was far too small to be likened to a cathedral.  We both remarked almost simultaneously on how light and airy it was in the general heat and agreed that this was the nicest we had seen.  Good architecture does impress.

We walked a lot, caught a horse cab, not much faster but a lot easier on the legs, and a taxi to go further out.  I caught the strange bug that troubled me off and on for the rest of the trip and made me quite ill ‘til this moment. 

But the hotel was nice, overlooking the Irrawaddy.

 

 

 

No comments

Travel

Cruising to PNG

 

 

 

 

On the 17th February 2020 Wendy and I set sail on Queen Elizabeth on a two week cruise up to Papua New Guinea, returning to Sydney on 2nd March. 

Read more: Cruising to PNG

Fiction, Recollections & News

Peter Storey McKie

 

 

My brother, Peter, is dead. 

One of his body's cells turned rogue and multiplied, bypassing his body's defences. The tumour grew and began to spread to other organs.  Radiation stabilised the tumour's growth but by then he was too weak for chemo-therapy, which might have stemmed the spreading cells.

He was 'made comfortable' thanks to a poppy grown in Tasmania, and thus his unique intelligence faded away when his brain ceased to function on Sunday, 22nd May 2022.

I visited him in the hospital before he died.  Over the past decade we had seldom spoken. Yet he now told me that he often visited my website. I had suspected this because from time to time he would send e-mail messages, critical of things I had said. That was about the only way we kept in touch since the death of his daughter Kate (Catherine). That poppy again.  

Read more: Peter Storey McKie

Opinions and Philosophy

Overthrow and the 'Arab Spring'

 

 

Back in April 2007 I was in Washington DC and wandered into a bookshop for a coffee.  On display was Stephen Kinzer's  National Best Seller: Overthrow: America's Century of Regime Change from Hawaii to Iraq.  So I bought it to read, before bed and on the plane. 

It is a heavily researched and work; very well described by the New York Times as: "A detailed passionate and convincing book... with the pace and grip of a good thriller."  And like a good thriller it was hard to put down.  I can recommend it.

Read more: Overthrow and the 'Arab Spring'

Terms of Use

Terms of Use                                                                    Copyright